MySacramento.Me - Sacramento, CA  

Check out the Sacramento Forums!   


Fight Tonight Over Nestle Bottled Water Plant!

As reported in Sacramento Press yesterday, the City of Sacramento issued a stop-work order on construction of a Nestle water-bottling plant in Sacramento, and at a 6pm meeting tonight the City Council will consider "amending the city's zoning code to immediately require special permits for beverage bottling plants."

The stop-work order is based on questions of whether or not Nestle filled out the appropriate paperwork to build the plant, and Brendan O'Rourke, who works for Nestle, says they did. The larger issue being asked by City Councilman Kevin McCarty and the advocacy group Save Our Water Sacramento is whether Nestle should be allowed to bottle water in Sacramento at all (full disclosure: I am friends with some of the members of Save Our Water Sacramento). While some of the water will be shipped in from nearby springs, the majority of the water Nestle wants to bottle, an estimated 81 million a year according to an article by McCarty in Sacramento Press, will be taken directly from Sacramento's municipal water supply, despite California being in its third year of drought. This water will then be resold to Californians (to avoid regulation by the FDA) at a profit of 10,000%!

Certainly, Sacramento has already made money off of the proposed plant; Nestle says they've already paid "'$3.7 million [. . .] in [the] form of permitting fees, construction costs, due diligence payments and [other associated] costs [. . .],'" and Mayor Kevin Johnson was quoted in another Sacramento Press article as saying the new plant could create "'40 to 60'" jobs. But do the costs outweigh the benefits? 40 to 60 jobs is certainly not a lot, and any money Sacramento has made so far will pale in comparison to what Nestle will make reselling tap water. Last week Save Our Water Sacramento hosted a special screening of the as-yet-unreleased documentary Tapped at The Crest. The film is pretty horrifying, detailing the problems with the bottled water industry: besides those already discussed, citizens in a city with a Nestle water-bottling plant in Maine were cut off from their water supply for two days while the plant's supply kept going; bottled water faces far less stringent safety requirements than bottled water and has been found by various studies to be contaminated; people who live near plants that create the plastic bottles for bottled water have a higher risk of getting cancer; and of course, water bottles that are not recycled often end up in the ocean, forming islands of plastic trash larger than Texas that are killing wildlife and affecting the food chain.

However, there are already two water-bottling plants in Sacramento, according to yet another Sacramento Press article (boy, they are on this issue!). And the best way to stop bottled water might be to simply stop drinking it. While I'm definitely a bleeding-heart liberal, I've drank my fair share of bottled water over the years (Tapped slackened my thirst for the stuff, however). A comment left on one of the Sacramento Press articles called local opponents of the Nestle plant "NIMBYs," an acronym that stands for "Not In My BackYard" and refers to people who enjoy the use of certain products or processes, such as nuclear power, but whom nevertheless refuse to let the uglier aspects of the product or processes, such as nuclear waste, come anywhere near their backyard. Those uglier aspects then end up in parts of the country or world where people are too poor to keep them out.

In any case, whether you oppose or support the Nestle plant, your voice can be heard tonight if you show up at the City Council meeting, and that's what democracy is all about!

The views and opinions of Jesse Baggs do not necessarily reflect those of and its other contributors.

posted Tuesday, October 27, 2009 by hardpressed jess


Photos: inside Arco Arena Inside Arco Arena
We get an insider-pass at Arco Arena and find some parts of the place few ever even knew existed.
Second Saturday and the Citzen Hotel Second Saturday & The Citizen
Midtown's "Mardi Gras 12 times a year" and Downtown's plush new digs at the Citizen Hotel promise for a fun night on the town.
MySacramento on Twitter Twitterific
All you Twitter tweeps out there, we're on board this crazy ride. Follow us until another social media app distracts us.
We Need a Few Good Bloggers!
Interested in blogging for MySacramento? As long as it's somewhat Sacramento related, we're looking for writers!
Dorm Survival at Sac State  Dorm Survival at Sac State 
Take a few tips from some seasoned veterans - from rooms to food to partying (and not getting caught), we'll give you the 411.
10 Things to Pack for College 10 Things to Pack for College
Packing for College? Jen Davies takes a look at 10... er... 11 things you can't forget when getting ready for that first year of college.
Sacramento Forums Sacramento Forums
See what's up in Sacramento... feel free to join the discussion, or just lurk until you find something worth saying.
Sacramento Bars & Restaurants Sacramento Bars & Restaurants
Been to a new restaurant or just looking to spread the word? We're always looking for new places to eat.
Sac State survival Sac State Survival
The origins of this site started at Sac State (a long, long time ago!). However some things stay the same. See what college life is life at Sacramento State.
Stuff to do in Sacramento Sacramento Scene
Looking for fun things to do? So are we! We'll provide some fun diversions her in and out of Sacramento.

- Sac Links -

Bite Club
Central City Opinion
Edible Sacramento
Elk Grove Online
Explore Sacramento
Good Day Sacramento
Joe Sacramento
Living In Urban Sac
Midtown Grid

Napkin Nights
River Wrap
Sac Bee 21Q
Sac Dine
Sac Forums
Sac Foodies
Sac Rag
Sacramento Press
Sac Scene
Sac Vibe
Twin Soup

[suggest a link

October 2008
November 2008
December 2008
January 2009
February 2009
March 2009
April 2009
May 2009
June 2009
July 2009
August 2009
September 2009
October 2009
November 2009
December 2009
January 2010
February 2010
March 2010
April 2010
May 2010
June 2010
July 2010
September 2010
October 2010
January 2012
March 2012
May 2012

Twitter Updates

    follow us on Twitter

    Like MySacramento?
    You might like




    The Tomato Pages Network - Sacramento Valley Community Websites is a member of the Tomato Pages Network. - sac blog, sacramento forum, sacramento restaurants, sac state, stuff to do - folsom news, articles, folsom forum, folsom yellow pages, - el dorado hills forum, el dorado hills restaurants - rancho cordova articles, rancho cordova forum - orangevale forum - granite bay forum - roseville forum

    Home | Advertise With Us | Contact Us

    local forums:
    citrus heights
    el dorado hills
    fair oaks
    granite bay
    rancho cordova

    local guides:

    local restaurants:
    el dorado hills

    the Tomato Pages Network

    Advertise on MySacramento